Your second job is taxed from the first pound with no allowance, and the payslip looks punitive. Usually that is correct. Sometimes it is not — and the difference is worth knowing.
You get one personal allowance, not one per job. Your main employer applies
the whole of it through a normal code like 1257L. The second
employer has none left to give, so HMRC issues BR — basic rate on
everything, from the first pound.
That is not a penalty for having two jobs. It is the system avoiding giving you the allowance twice, which would leave you underpaid and facing a bill. The tax code checker will tell you what any code on either job is doing.
The total is what matters, not the split. Two jobs paying £20,000 and £8,000 should cost the same tax as one job paying £28,000. If it does not, something in the codes is wrong — not the fact of the second job.
| Your situation | BR on job 2? | What should happen |
|---|---|---|
| Main job pays over £12,570 | Correct | Allowance is fully used by job 1. Nothing to fix |
| Main job pays under £12,570 | Overpaying | Part of your allowance is going unused. Ask HMRC to split it |
| Combined income over £50,270 | Underpaying | BR takes 20% where 40% is due. Expect a bill unless the code is changed to D0 |
| Job 2 is your only job now | Wrong | Job 1 ended and HMRC has not caught up. Send the P45 |
The expensive case is the one that looks fine. If two jobs
together push you over £50,270, BR deducts 20% on the second job
where 40% is owed. Nothing looks wrong on either payslip, and the shortfall
surfaces later as an underpayment collected through next year's code. The
second job tax
calculator shows the combined position rather than one job at a time.
If your main job pays less than the personal allowance, some of it is going
to waste. HMRC can divide the allowance between employers — for example
600L on one and 657L on the other. You ask by
contacting HMRC with both employers' PAYE references and an estimate of what
each will pay.
Worth doing when the main job is part-time or seasonal. Not worth doing when the main job already exceeds the allowance, because there is nothing left to move. The hourly wage calculator is a quick way to estimate what a variable-hours job will actually pay over a year.
Income tax is cumulative across the year and self-corrects. National Insurance is not: it is calculated per job, per pay period, with each employment getting its own threshold.
Two jobs at £9,000 each pay little or no employee NI, because neither crosses the threshold on its own — a genuine advantage. But the reverse also holds: NI is never reconciled across jobs at year end the way income tax is, so you cannot reclaim it by filing. The National Insurance calculator shows the per-job position.
This is the one place two jobs can beat one. £18,000 from a single employer pays employee NI on everything above the threshold. Split across two employers at £9,000 each, much of it falls below both thresholds. Income tax treats the two cases identically; NI does not.
1257L on one and BR on the other is the normal pattern; two codes with allowances is not, and will cause an underpayment.References: tax code decoder for any code on either job, payslip glossary for the abbreviations, and adjusted net income if the combined figure is nearing a threshold.
Not tax advice. This explains published HMRC rules. Your coding notice and HMRC are the authorities on your own codes.